Bin Tax / Household Tax / Water Tax Public Private Partnerships are already privatising our public water system 13:00 Dec 19 0 comments Irish Water: Killing off conservation and the real agenda behind water charges 12:03 Jan 18 2 comments RTÉ Primetime Parrots State Propaganda on Water Charges 19:39 Dec 14 1 comments Defeating the water charges - Don’t be fooled by the concessions 23:28 Dec 02 0 comments Water Charges and TTIP! 01:15 Nov 16 0 comments more >>Blog Feeds
Anti-EmpireThis Site Will Soon Be Hosted at anti-em... Sun Sep 22, 2024 17:24 | Anti-Empire Ukraine Shoots Down F-16 With Patriot, A... Sat Aug 31, 2024 11:53 | Anti-Empire Surprise Offensive Puts 300 km² of Russ... Fri Aug 09, 2024 08:44 | Marko Marjanović The Wholesome Photo of the Month Thu May 09, 2024 11:01 | Anti-Empire In 3 War Years Russia Will Have Spent $3... Thu May 09, 2024 02:17 | Anti-Empire
Human Rights in IrelandPromoting Human Rights in Ireland
Lockdown Skeptics
Man Says He Has Been ?Left to Rot? After Covid Vaccine ? BBC Report Mon Oct 14, 2024 19:30 | Will Jones
Why I?ve Never Read a Sally Rooney Novel and I?m Not Going to Start Now Mon Oct 14, 2024 17:19 | Steven Tucker
Harris Pledges to Legalise Recreational Marijuana and Create ?Forgivable? Loans in Bid to Win Black ... Mon Oct 14, 2024 15:38 | Will Jones
The Hezbollah Tunnel 100 Metres From a UN Base Mon Oct 14, 2024 13:10 | Will Jones
Baroness Royall, Leading Candidate in Oxford Chancellorship Race, Runs Into Free Speech Row Mon Oct 14, 2024 11:00 | Toby Young
Voltaire NetworkVoltaire, international editionVoltaire, International Newsletter N°103 Fri Oct 11, 2024 12:15 | en The Anglo-Saxons carry on bombing Yemen, although West Point considers it ineffe... Fri Oct 11, 2024 12:07 | en Voltaire, International Newsletter N°102 Tue Oct 08, 2024 07:00 | en Iran and Israel, by Thierry Meyssan Tue Oct 08, 2024 06:58 | en Assassination of Hassan Nasrallah Tue Oct 08, 2024 06:50 | en |
Violence And The Jobstown Anti-Water Charges Protest.
national |
bin tax / household tax / water tax |
opinion/analysis
Monday November 17, 2014 11:37 by anon paraickhackett at gmail dot com
Should this violence be criticised? It is clear that the governments is seeking to split the anti-water charges campaign by modifying the water charges and publicly attacking any violence surrounding the protests. A public attack has been mounted by figures from the government parties against the Socialist Party because of the violence surrounding the protest against water charges in Tallaght.These figures, including Joan Burton, claim that the protest had a violent nature and that Joan Burton was subjected to a physical attack and intimidation by the protesters. The SP claims that generally the protest was peaceful and that a few non-protesters were responsible for the violence. It declares that it is against the use of violence such as water bombs being lobbed at government figures. |
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (8 of 8)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8No, the organizers of a law abiding protest are NOT coming out against the other sort of protest if/when they are objecting to the other sort making it impossible for them to hold a law abiding protest. BOTH are tactics that may be useful, and even if we disagree about that (how useful) certainly those who want to do either sort should be allowed to do so.
But those who are trying to do a law abiding protest are hindered in their preferred tactic if the other sort are using them for cover to carry our their tactic. Those of you who favor more forceful means need to take that into account and not do your action in a way that interferes with other protesters.
Oh, you say, separating ourselves out like that would make it too easy for the authorities to come for us. We want/need innocent bystanders to hide behind. Sorry, you are out of line there and doubly so if you then attack those you were trying to hide behind for criticizing you.
Understand? I am NOT criticizing your tactic in and of itself (attack with water balloons) but whether you needed more separation between yourselves and other protesters.
what happened in tallagh was not violent or i'm not sure what your definition of violence actually is?
A water Balloon was thrown at Minister Burton by youths I think this was a symbolic jest rather than actual
violence otherwise those youths would of been arrested without doubt.
I would accept that she genuinely was intimidated because of the anger of the protesters,
i would also say that anger is justified in that marginalized community.
The water balloon incident pales in comparison to What i seen on social media of the protest outside of the
mansion house.
This was true violence when a Woman protester stepped in front of a the taxpayers ministerial car.
The young women was violently flung to the ground by three large policemen and was seriously injured when she struck a pole.
No sense of outrage here when a citizen excercises there democratic right to protest.on such a contentious issue.
This is from the WSM facebook page and presents a decent view of what the establishment are doing
After weeks of Garda provocation, and just after Garda beat protesters with batons someone finally snapped and threw a single brick back. When a politician as unpopular as Joan Burton uses dozens of riot police to force her way into and out of one of the most deprived communities in the state, what should be expected but angry protest. And when at a moment of unprecedented popular mobilisation those same Garda pull pepper spray & batons for use against water charge resistors what is a single brick bouncing off a car in response.
Of course the mainstream media and political establishment will seize this to try and divide the movement, to set ‘good protester’ against ‘bad protester’. We reject this. The real issue is why is this unpopular tax being imposed and why is Garda violence being used against those who dare to protest. Yes the establishment has chosen to escalate rather than back down, our approach must be unity in the face of that attack and rejection of any attempt to scapegoat those the state tries to criminalise.
Joan Burton can probably consider herself very lucky that in one of the communities that has suffered most from her government's policies, all that happened was she was delayed for a couple of hours. Her government's policies have visited a lot of violence on families in Jobstown and elsewhere
Still image is from Sunday World video which shows a very large riot squad deployment shoving people off the road and edges of road to make way for Burton's convoy moments before a figure appears to throw an object which bounces off a Garda car - see http://www.sundayworld.com/top-stories/news/protesters-...s-car
And a snapshot of true role of the gardai. To prevent the will of the people breaking out and maintain the system for capitalism
Courtsey of WSM twitter feed
Caption: Video Id: g8GinTeLFq4 Type: Youtube Video
Paul Murphy TD was stripped half naked at water protest today in Jobstown Tallaght
Apparently the gardai discharged a previously standing warrant and arrested a young man in the vicinity of the protest.
It seems likely that the friends of this "young man" with an arrest warrant hanging over him were the ones who targetted the
garda car in response to the arrest of their friend.
Why did the gardai chose this time to discharge that warrant?
It's a poor area, there were a lot of people on the IW protest earlier. the media were about bristling with cameras and no doubt the young man's mates were about, annoyed that their friend was nicked and sitting in a garda car, and likely no friends of an Garda siochana either!!
a provocation to get a response which could be "media linked" to the protest perhaps?
The brick was thrown AFTER the protest but the media are intent on conflating the incident with the protesters. Disgusting!!
some discussion of media coverage by indo here
The media showed their true colours in their portrayal of the protesters and their distorted use of language. No doubt this child's water balloon will be used as the excuse to beef up police presence at future protests as is always the case.
Our media have lost their role as moral agents and clearly cannot be trusted
Perhaps now more folks will begin to understand the pattern in what happened to the shell to sea protesters when the media began to demonise them whenever they protested, and how the gardai got ever more brutal and their numbers got ever larger.
Beware of agent provocateurs in your midst advocating violence coupled with the presence of presstitute media. Agent provocateurs are often people undercover in state employment. They act genuine but use their influence in the group to steer protests towards acts which will discredit the movement then compliant media demonisation does the rest.
Learn form the rossport experience, protest peacefully but assertively. Paddy wants you to "do as thou wilt" but that just plays into the hands of the media and the government. There is really no point in going off half cocked at a water protest. It's just dumb behaviour.
I don't know what the hell Paddy is up to here, but quite frankly it stinks of provocateur behaviour to me.
Violence has it's place in protest when all other avenues of redress are exhausted, but it is certainly not required to win this battle. The government is quite clearly under pressure. All that is required in this campaign is to just keep up the large numbers and non violent protests and they will undoubtedly fold. Then maintain the positive feeling of power this gives you and fight them in the same manner next time they try it on. Because the fact is, the people really do have power but only when we coalesce. We just have to exercise our power together . Then No Government, however corrupt or violent, can resist us..
The water balloon was nothing. Kids throw those at each other. But you have to remember that the ruling classes live in deep fear and paranoia of the people rising up because they know that they have routinely lied to the people what they are up to is wrong and that they are taking advantage of the people for the gain of a few. They know that if it was them on the other side things would indeed turn violent. But it is to the credit of the Irish people that 99.9% of them remained dignified and peaceful while making their power felt and sending a chill up the spine of the political class. Keep it up folks.
How does the above relate to coverage of the Jobstown protest I wonder!!
There's a war happening in the media at the moment and there was a moment on RTE's Prime Time last night that exemplified this, a woman in the audience described women being assaulted by Gardai on her estate. She specified that they were not near the IW workers when it happened and the ex Fine Gael woman Gemma Hussey basically scoffed at her and said something to the effect of, 'yes becasue you were blocking workers that's why it happened'. The woman didn't retort probably because of the temporary shock and confusion this kind of comment causes, which is the desired effect.
This is 'gaslighting' and it's been used by a lot of Fine Gael td's in debates in relation to the water charges and other issues, I don't know if it's linked to NLP training that they're getting or if it's just instinctual. It's basically taking taking something that somebody has said and flipping it back on them to paint them as the perpetrator as opposed to the victim. It happened with the woman who was flung outside the mansion house also, there were comments such as 'she shouldn't have been near the car' or ' The gardai were only doing their job', she was callously manhandled and thrown towards a rock hard object and somehow it was her fault!. Gaslighting is used by psychopaths and proto-psychopaths in the home, the office all the way up to the Daíl and if more people were aware of it the easier it will be to shoot down in debates.
The unrest at the Jobstown protest was blown out of all proportion and the arrest of the teenager was very suspect in it's timing. The media will try and frame the debate and feign horror at a water balloon being thrown and the gaslighting will continue. I don't envy Paul Murphy as they will throw everything they have at him with this and try and paint him as a devil as a distraction as much as anything else. The real proof of this campaign will be if the critical mass of people refuse to pay the bills when they arrive, to see the government defeated on this would be sweet, sweet wine and to see them having to call a general election would be even sweeter.
reports from RTE
There were protests outside Leinster House during the afternoon debates
Around 60 water charge protesters are in a standoff with contractors in Donaghmede in Dublin.
rish Water said 90 contractor staff are being prevented from carrying out work in the Grange Road area.
The protest followed a similar action yesterday when workers with GMC/Sierra were prevented from leaving for nine hours.
There are 13 vans parked on Grange Road and local protesters prevented vans from leaving by standing in front of them when they tried to move.
The vans and uncompleted meter installation sites have notices of a High Court order warning protesters not to interfere.
Gardaí are at the scene.
Meanwhile Business Plus magazine, a magazine for the capitalist class, calls it for what it is: Class War
Water Charges Protest = The Class War
Tweeted at irishwater
silent protest by women at Coolock Garda station over alleged brutality to water protestors #rtenews #irishwater