Israeli sinks to even greater depths of depravity. Israeli drones lure Palestinians with crying chil... 21:39 Apr 18 0 comments Israel Continues to Shoot Itself in the Foot 20:25 Dec 16 0 comments Is the Gaza-Israel Fighting “A False Flag”? They Let it Happen? Their Objective Is “to Wipe Gaza Off... 00:48 Oct 21 1 comments Israel Confesses War Crime 23:49 Oct 10 0 comments Ukraine and West prepare media space for their potential false flag attack on Zaporozhye NPP 23:34 Jun 26 1 comments more >>Blog Feeds
Anti-EmpireNorth Korea Increases Aid to Russia, Mos... Tue Nov 19, 2024 12:29 | Marko Marjanovi? Trump Assembles a War Cabinet Sat Nov 16, 2024 10:29 | Marko Marjanovi? Slavgrinder Ramps Up Into Overdrive Tue Nov 12, 2024 10:29 | Marko Marjanovi? ?Existential? Culling to Continue on Com... Mon Nov 11, 2024 10:28 | Marko Marjanovi? US to Deploy Military Contractors to Ukr... Sun Nov 10, 2024 02:37 | Field Empty
The SakerA bird's eye view of the vineyard
Alternative Copy of thesaker.is site is available Thu May 25, 2023 14:38 | Ice-Saker-V6bKu3nz
The Saker blog is now frozen Tue Feb 28, 2023 23:55 | The Saker
What do you make of the Russia and China Partnership? Tue Feb 28, 2023 16:26 | The Saker
Moveable Feast Cafe 2023/02/27 ? Open Thread Mon Feb 27, 2023 19:00 | cafe-uploader
The stage is set for Hybrid World War III Mon Feb 27, 2023 15:50 | The Saker
Public InquiryInterested in maladministration. Estd. 2005RTEs Sarah McInerney ? Fianna Fail?supporter? Anthony Joe Duffy is dishonest and untrustworthy Anthony Robert Watt complaint: Time for decision by SIPO Anthony RTE in breach of its own editorial principles Anthony Waiting for SIPO Anthony
Voltaire NetworkVoltaire, international editionRussia Prepares to Respond to the Armageddon Wanted by the Biden Administration ... Tue Nov 26, 2024 06:56 | en Voltaire, International Newsletter N?109 Fri Nov 22, 2024 14:00 | en Joe Biden and Keir Starmer authorize NATO to guide ATACMS and Storm Shadows mis... Fri Nov 22, 2024 13:41 | en Donald Trump, an Andrew Jackson 2.0? , by Thierry Meyssan Tue Nov 19, 2024 06:59 | en Voltaire, International Newsletter N?108 Sat Nov 16, 2024 07:06 | en |
Mordechai Vanunu Asks for an Irish Welcome
international |
anti-war / imperialism |
feature
Saturday October 09, 2004 00:36 by Vanunu2Ireland - Vanunu to Ireland Campaign
Indymedia.ie Interviews Mordechai Vanunu
In 1986 Mordechai Vanunu offered information about Israel's secret Dimona nuclear 'research center' programme to The Sunday Times, later that year he was drugged and kidnapped in Italy by Israeli agents, was tried and convicted in Israel for treason and spent eighteen years in Ashkelon prison, twelve of which were in solitary confinement in a two-by-three metre cell. Today, having completed his sentence, Vanunu is free from prison but not Free to leave Israel - he is under constant monitoring by the Israeli Authorities and faces threats to his life while living in Israel. His restrictions include not speaking to international journalists. Mordechai Vanunu has violated court orders by speaking to Indymedia.ie... "I would like to get out of Israel and start a new life. I hope the Irish government will help me to receive asylum and much more importantly to act, as a government, [to convince the Israelis] to let me go. That is what I need now. We need someone to ask the Israeli government to let me go. If I were to come to Ireland, I would like to write my book. I have an obligation to write my book for people who want to know my story. I would like to speak to people about anti-nuclear weapons, to speak about peace, and, if I can, to enter university to learn and teach." Indymedia.ie: Could you briefly describe what happened with you and the Dimona Nuclear Plant 18+ years ago that resulted in your imprisonment, for those who are not familiar? Mordechai Vanunu: In September of 1986 I met a journalist, Peter Hounam, from The Sunday Times, and I gave him all the information I knew about Dimona Nuclear Reactor where I was working. I told him I was working in the production of Plutonium, Lithium-6 and Tritium Nuclear Materials that are used for producing and building Atomic Bombs, Hydrogen Bombs and Neutron Bombs. My job was to produce these materials. I used to produce each year about 30 to 40 grams of Plutonium, which is enough for about 10 Atomic Bombs each year. So if you consider that the Dimona Reactor was working since from 1964 to 1986, they produced about 200 Atomic Bombs.
Indymedia.ie: What led you to the decision to release this information to the public? Vanunu: It was published by The Sunday Times, and the main reason I went to the public is because the Israeli Government was not reporting to anyone what was going on in secret. All that was known was that maybe Israel had two to five Atomic Bombs - but I knew that they were producing a lot. So I decided that the world should know that they Israel had a lot of Atomic bombs, beyond any imagination. And that it is a danger that they could use them in the next war against Syria or any other state. By publishing [this information] and informing the world, I wanted to prevent Israel from using nuclear bombs and causing nuclear war in the Middle East. And also,I hoped that because of the publicity Israel would have to make peace with the Palestinians and give back the occupied land. That was my main target and concern, to help to bring peace to the Middle East, and to prevent war. Indymedia.ie: What led you to develop your own anti-nuclear stance? Vanunu: I think every human being who followed the story of nuclear weapons - consider Hiroshima, Nagasaki - can see the result of the use of Atomic Bombs like as in the movie 'The Day After'. And do not forget that in the Cold War, when the United States and Russia were in a nuclear race, each one had thousands of nuclear weapons and were very close to an explosive situation - that would cause the deaths of millions and the destruction of cities of the world or in the Middle East. So, my main concern was to save and prevent a genocide and holocaust by Israel's nuclear weapons. I was raised to respect the Jewish holocaust - and I found out that the Jewish people and Israeli government could cause a holocaust on the Arab people by nuclear weapons - that was my target and main concern. Indymedia.ie: Obviously, the Israeli government would say they need them for 'security' - but do nuclear weapons create security for Israel, ultimately? Vanunu: I do not think that nuclear weapons are defensive weapons and do not save any life. Nuclear weapons can only cause genocide and holocaust, nuclear weapons cannot save an Israeli State. The only way to save an Israeli State is by a real peace. The use of nuclear weapons can only cause a nuclear war or a chemical weapons war that will kill millions of people. So I disagree [with the Israeli nuclear policy] that these weapons are for defense. In my view, nuclear power gives too much power to the Israeli government so they can avoid making peace. Indymedia.ie: Your convictions have led you to eighteen years of imprisonment and many years in isolation in jail. Can you describe your life in prison? Vanunu: I was eleven and a half years in total isolation in one small room - two by three meters. They did not use any physical torture, but they used a lot of psychological torture to make me angry and agressive - if I were agressive, they could have used physical power against me. But I was not agressive so I did not give them the chance to use physical torture. But there was a lot of psychological torture, every day and every night they could disturb my sleep, they came to my cell every half-hour, they controlled everything from food to clothes, even electricity and water - all was under Israeli spy control. The Shikma prison [in Ashkelon] was controlled and guided by Shin-beth/Mossad - they have their office inside the prison and use that power to recruit the guards and train them to use modern psychological systems to break down [the prisoners] - but I survived, and fought back by staying very firm and strong.
Indymedia.ie: You have had an interesting global spiritual journey., You started your life as a Jew in Morocco, then later in Nepal and developed an interest in Buddhism, and then in Australia you converted to Christianity. I am curious, did your spirituality help you through your isolation in prison? Vanunu: Yes, I was raised as a Jew in a Jewish family (in Morocco) and I became a Christian in Sydney, Australia in 1986. That helped me very much when I was in prison because when I was isolated in a cell I used to be under heavy psychological brainwashing - I needed my own faith, my own way, my individual way, my independent way. So, the best way for me to answer all the Israeli brainwashing was through my Christianity - no matter what they did they could not change me or break me down, because I declared my Christianity, very firm and clear, in my own way. I said to them 'You are in the wrong way and I am in the right way' and I am following Jesus Christ, non-violence and peace. My Christianity was like a shell that helped me to stand against all their brainwashing and [psychological] warfare. This was a big obstacle for them in their effort to break me. Indymedia.ie: Did your Christianity influence you to make the decision to release the information about the Dimona Nuclear Programme? Vanunu: Yes, when I was in Australia [and converted to Christianity] this set me totally free from any obligation or connection to the Israeli government or to the Israeli Nation - I felt I was doing right for all of the human race, that I was not obligated (as before) only to the Israeli state. The human race is more important than loyalty to the Israeli government. Christianity helped me feel that I am one of all the human race, like Jesus brought God to all the world. Indymedia.ie: I do not know the full conditions of your release from prison, but I read that you had recently visited the Wall that Israel is building. A lot has changed since you were imprisoned in 1986, what does that Wall symbolise to you? Vanunu: When I came out of prison and saw this Wall, it was very disappointing and very disturbing. The Wall is a symbol of Israeli aggression and power and a sign that it does not really want peace. Israel is building this wall to be an obstacle to any movement between Jews and Palestinians and to disturb Palestinian life; but more importantly this wall is a symbol that Israel does not want real peace. You cannot have real peace with Palestinians if you build this wall. So, I am very disapointed to see this wall and I want the world and the whole human race to raise their voice to demand the destruction of this wall. It means that there is not going to be any real peace in the future. Indymedia.ie: How is it that Israel can think that Nuclear Weapons and this Wall can bring it peace? Vanunu: I do not understand it. The Israelis believe they have the power to do anything they want. And with the Wall, they can prevent a real peace. The Wall is the true face of Israeli policy, that they do not want any real peace. They have a policy based on power instead of going into real negotiations to create real peace with the Arabs of the Middle East, and especially the Palestinians. The Wall and Israel's nuclear weapons reminds me of Masada. The Jewish people lived on that mountain near the Dead Sea in 73AD and in the end they committed suicide there. This is also the policy of nuclear weapons. If they use nuclear weapons it will be a genocide for the Israelis. Indymedia.ie: How do you see Israel's nuclear weapons assisting the oppression of the Palestinians? Vanunu: It means that Israel trusts its own power and can force the Palestinians and the world, including Europe and the United States, to accept a Jewish Apartheid State. A Jewish State with Jewish religion and law: they call it democracy, but it is Jewish democracy for the Jews. This is the policy backed by nuclear weapons. Instead of building a real secular democracy for all the people and a real democracy as in every European state, Israel decided to have a religious Apartheid state, a state governed by Jewish law for the Jews only, with no respect for Palestinian rights. This is what the Israelis have in mind with nuclear weapons and this is a big mistake. Maybe now they will start to realise this, they will wake up and change this policy and build a real democracy - and in a real democracy they will not need any nuclear weapons.
Indymedia.ie: What are the conditions of your release from jail? Vanunu: I am under restriction not to speak to foreigners for six months since April 21st, and not to leave the country for one year. After six months they will review my restriction on speaking to foreigners - but I am already speaking to foreigners, all the time. So far, they have not done anything. I think they realise it is a stupid restriction because you cannot make a distinction between Israelis and non-Israelis when you speak. [The restriction] is about my rights as a human being and my political views. They will review it on October 21st and then we will see if they continue or stop it. Indymedia.ie: Do you believe that the Israeli State is monitoring you today? Vanunu: I believe that the Israeli spies, Mossad-Shin-beth, are monitoring me, my phone, my email, they know what I am doing. They are reading the news, following the media and Internet, they have a lot of information. Indymedia.ie: So, they are probably listening to our conversation at this moment? Vanunu: I believe so! But we are not doing anything wrong. I am repeating information that was published eighteen years ago or speaking my political views. If this is a democracy they should not fear me speaking. Indymedia.ie: What other threats do you feel while living in Israel? From either political or religious groups? Vanunu: I do not feel totally free. I have said that I am free but [with the restrictions] not totally free. I cannot travel freely within Israel, I cannot go on the streets because some right-wing religious Jews are opposed to me. Some of this is the result of the Israeli media creating a bad image of my case to Israelis. So a lot of people do not like me. So I do not feel free and I am not traveling in Israeli cities, I am staying only in East Jerusalem among Palestinians and among Christians and foreigners. The only way I will feel free is when I get out of Israel and go to another state, in Europe or the United States. Indymedia.ie: If you were to come to Ireland, what would you like to do with your new freedom here? Vanunu: I would like to get out of Israel and start a new life. I hope the Irish government will help me to receive asylum and much more importantly to act, as a government, [to convince the Israelis] to let me go. That is what I need now. We need someone to ask the Israeli government to let me go. If I were to come to Ireland, I would like to write my book. I have an obligation to write my book for people who want to know my story. I would like to speak to people about anti-nuclear weapons, to speak about peace, and, if I can, to enter university to learn and teach. Indymedia.ie: What are the chances that the Israeli Courts are going to allow you to leave the country? And, do you believe that the Israeli Courts are under political pressure to keep you within Israel? Vanunu: We appealed to the Court already [about the restrictions] and it was rejected. The Courts are in the power of the government and used secret evidence that I was not allowed to hear. Without me or my lawyer being present, the government convinced a judge to continue the restrictions. So, I do not have any future in the courts. I do not expect any justice from the Courts.
Indymedia.ie: What are the chances of political pressure within Israel being applied to allow your release from the restrictions? Vanunu: Some negotiation by a foreign government or intervention by a European state [is needed] demanding that I be let go, explaining to the Israeli government that I do not have any secrets that can harm Israel, that I am going to restart my life. They should let me go as I have no more secrets to give - only what was published eighteen years ago. So, I hope that a foreign state will come out and demand of them that they let me go. Either Ireland or the European Parliament, or indeed anyone. Indymedia.ie: Are there any political parties in Israel that are pressuring the government for your freedom? Vanunu: In Israel you will not find any political powers who are supporting me. Only some Palestinian Arab members of the Knesset Parliament. They themselves do not have any power and they are regarded as Israel's enemies. Inside Israel, you will not even find one non-Arab member of the Knesset who will stand and speak on my behalf. Because, on this issue of nuclear weapons, Israel is of one mind - Israelis are for nuclear weapons and they will not support me because I speak against nuclear weapons and because I want to make Israel a nuclear weapons-free zone. Indymedia.ie: So, you believe this is a situation where only external pressure can give you your political and human rights? Vanunu: Only foreign governments and external powers can convince them to let me go. If the Israelis are really a democracy they would respect my rights, my freedom of movement and my freedom of speech. Some people from abroad have spoken very clearly to Israel telling them they should respect these human rights and let me go. I have served eighteen years - what they want. The full sentence. Even killers in Israel do not serve eighteen years! So they should let me go. It is only a matter of revenge and they continue because I am a Christian. If I were Jewish I could be free a long time ago.
Vanunu: I want to say that I have read a lot about Irish people and Irish culture. I read Irish books while in prison and enjoyed them very much. Including James Joyce's Ulysses, also books of poems by Seamus Heaney - I had learned that he knew about me and sent his support. I also read of Irish history. I think Ireland now has come out after a long sleep in the 19th and 20th Century and has now got a real status in Europe. I have many friends in Ireland who used to write me during my [prison] years, sending me books. I would love to come to Ireland. Last night I enjoyed my first drink of Guinness, it was wonderful. I hope that Ireland will be proud enough and great enough to speak on my behalf to Israel (and ask Israel) to let me go. And I will be glad to stay in Ireland. I give my thanks to Ireland and the Irish people and hope one day I can visit Dublin and stay there. Indymedia.ie: Thank you for this interview and when you come to Ireland there will be many people who would be happy to buy you many pints of Guinness. Vanunu: OK! Slán go fóill. |
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (16 of 16)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16Ali Ahmed Halimeh
Delegate-General,
Palestinian Authority to Ireland
Yours,
Garret FitzGerald
Fine Gael
Former Taoiseach
He is a great humanitarian, who has paid a high price for telling the truth about Israeli nuclear weapons. He spoke because he wants to save Israel and the world from nuclear disaster. We are all indebted to him, and offering asylum, friendship, and support, may go a little way to repaying the debt humanity owes Mordechai for his courage and the sacrifice he made for us all.
Mairead Corrigan Maguire
Peace People
1976 Nobel Peace Laureate
The treatment of Mr. Vanunu by the Israeli authorities has been shameful. He was illegally kidnapped by Israeli agents from Rome in 1986 and was forced to serve his 18 year sentence in virtual solitary confinement. Even his release from prison has not brought freedom. Under restrictions imposed on him he is barred from leaving the country, approaching air or sea ports, meeting foreign nationals or moving house.
I believe that it would now be an appropriate humanitarian gesture for this country to indicate that it would be willing to consider offering Mr. Vanunu asylum and he certainly appears to meet all the criteria for the granting of asylum. It would also make up to some extent for the fact that Ireland and other European countries looked the other way when he was being kidnapped and treated so shamefully by the Israeli authorities.
Michael D. Higgins TD
Labour Party
Enda Kenny
Fine Gael Leader
Is mise,
Aengus Ó Snodaigh TD
Sinn Féin
Joe Higgins TD
Socialist Party
Joe Costello, TD
Labour
Daniel Ellsberg
Whistle Blower of the 'Pentagon Papers'
Member of Whistle Blower Project
Katharine Gun
Whistle Blower in the case of US spying on UN Security Council in 2003
Member of Whistle Blower Project
His human rights have got to be respected. I also call on the Irish Government to invite him to Ireland to further our anti-nuclear stance on the International stage
Finian McGrath TD
Ciarán Cuffe TD
Green Party
Under the Geneva Convention on the Status of Refugees 1951, any person such as Mordechai Vanunu who has "a well-founded fear of being persecuted" in his own country is entitled refegee status in a safe country such as Ireland. It is clear that Vanunu has been persecuted in the past, that this persecution is continuing at present, and likely to continue into the future for as long as he remains in Israel. In view of the assassination policies being pursued by the present Israeli government against those they perceive to be the enemies of Israel, there is a real and genuine fear that Vanunu's life will be at risk for as long as he remains in Israel.
I strongly recommend therefore that Mordechai be granted refugee status in Ireland under the Geneva Convention.
Edward Horgan
Retired Irish Army Commandant
Trevor Sargent, TD
Green Party Leader
Peter McVerry SJ Jesuit Priest in Ballymun
Joe Murray
Action From Ireland (Afri)
Dr Ronit Lentin
Lecturer in Sociology Trinity College Dublin
Coalition Against Deportation of Irish Children
Tom Hyland
Campaigner for Independence and Human Rights in East Timor
I would strongly desire that Ireland should acknowledge this man's contribution, by offering him the asylum he appears to seek here. The prophetic sacrifice he made against nuclear war is an inspiration for us all.
Fr. Patrick Rogers c.p.
Assoc. Professor of Biblical Studies
Milltown Institute, Dublin
I ask Michael McDowell to consider inviting Vanunu to Ireland at the earliest opportunity.
Rosanna Flynn,
Residents Against Racism
Mr Vannunu should not have to seek assylum anywhere.As a consciencious objector and bringer of truth, he should be welcomed by all as a person who cares for peace and the preservation of life.
If Vanunu were simply a conscientious objector to nuclear weapons he might have some credibility. It is clear, however, that his agenda is much wider than this. He parrots all the standard anti-Israel vitriol which makes no effort to understand the dilemma that the Israelis are in as they seek to defend themselves against murder and mayhem.
I object to him quoting his "christianity" as a sort of shield and defence against the Jewish people. Christianity properly experienced and understood leads one rather to love the Jews and seek their welfare. And this - in case someone jumps on this point - in no way implies lack of love for Arabs.
Whichever way you look at Vanunu he still committed two faults.
First he was in breach of official secrets and treason legislation so, " If you can't do the time don't do the crime."
Second he committed the political error of giving the Arab world excuses to accelerate their NBC alias WMD programmes.
As such he aggravated a situation that did not need it. He poured oil or rather nukes on the fire.
Yours faithfully,
Frank Adam
I cannot believe we still get the same one law for the rich style excuse from Zionists and their excusers. What if Vannunu were Iraqi, no doubt you, being a "balanced" individual, would then be saying Saddam was right to have Vannunu incarcerated and killed because he was a traitor? Despite your pathetic claims that real Israeli WMD give their neighbours an "excuse" for developing their own WMD, there is still be a big difference in that Saddam had NO WMD whereas the Israelis have 200-400 and more importantly have the satellites, ballistic missiles and submarine-launched cruise missiles to deliver them with. Vannunu is a hero in the world fight against nuclear arms proliferation, an area in which the state of Israel is one of the key offenders! As Bremner said last night on C4 Bush & Blair (and the Zionists) are now operating on the principle that Hope is a WMD (Weapon of Mass Deception). There is another word beginning with H to describe people like you, Hypocrite! There is also a word beginning with L ..............
He is clearly acting out of conscience, and he's "paid his debt to society" etc. However, relocation to Ireland is the last thing he needs. He should be relocating in the USA where he can have a louder and more effective voice (and make more money). Besides, if anyone needs to hear him in Ireland, I'm sure public school boys and girls from the Philosophical Society or Historical Society in Trinners can extend him an invite - yah?
apart from the suprious comments about Ireland, you are wrong in claiming that Vannunu started the nuclear arms race in the Middle-East. Firstly Israel started it on their own following the establishment of the Israeli state in 1948 and secondly there is only a race if there are 2 credible parties, which there aren't. In fact Israel helped start the nuclear arms race on the Indian sub-continent by helping the Indians with their first nuclear test in 1974, which predates Vannunu by over a decade and led to the development of the first muslim bomb by Pakistan. Yet another Israeli own-goal!
What none of your correspondents realises is that that Vanunu is probably a great Israeli hero.
The scenario is the following. Israel possesses a nuclear capability to which it must not admit openly and defiantly, for fear of antagonizing its allies - principally the US which is pressing for non-proliferation.
What use is a deterrent if the enemy is not convinced that it exists? The only method is to enlist a loyal Israeli to simulate the role of 'whistleblower'. If he enacts sufficiently convincingly the 'outsider' persona - perhaps converting to Christianity was a bit over the top! - the Arabs may find the information credible. Of course, the weak link is the unbelievable naivety of being lured to captivity by a pretty woman, but all James Bond fans will go along with this. He then spends a long period sufficiently concealed from the world so that his 5* accomodation, top cuisine, all cable and prime movies on TV, endless supply of pretty nanas, are not evident to the outside observer.
Result? Eighteen years of peace in that part of the Middle East, with no Arab country willing to take the risk of attacking a nuclear-equipped super-power.
Whether this scenario was enacted wittingly or unwittingly it still makes Vanunu Israel’s greatest patriot, and one of Mossad’s greatest coups!
Israel's top secret(*) - even more than the Dimona bombs - is that the court in Israel is totally corupted.
The newspapers don't write about it, and one honest MP member who at my request asked for investigation, very soon found herself ex MP. Her name is Tamar Gozanski, and she was the only MP (from about 40 MP considered Leftists/Humanitarian to whom I applied ) who was ready, after I provided her with my findings, to fight the corruption
The coruption in court is covered up by the media (also the story about MP Gozanski was hushed up, although journalists to whom I spoke said that its a great story) and not a word leaks.
The demon is kept tightly in the bottle.
Even the Dimona-demon is more free.
The only outlet I have is the internet, and I have reason to fear that this window of oportunity will soon close.
Meanwhile I publish my articles in israel.indymedia.org ( in Hebrew).
As the court and the media are controlled by the Plutocrats, who also control government-parlament -
Israel is not a Democracy.
More likely a Demon-cracy.
---------
* formaly speaking, as the public is very much aware of the coruption.
Vanunu can not lead a normal life in Israel as the "Man from Dimona" is demonised, and all media participate in the witch-hunt.
His personal safety is at stake in Israel, and I am sure that he can't walk freely in the street.
Therefore its of utmost importance that Vanunu finds a home away from home.
Another Jo Moore moment - methinks.
The police international investigations unit detained nuclear whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu on Thursday morning for questioning related to an ongoing probe examining suspicions he leaked national secrets and violated legal rulings since his release from prison.
Prior to Vanunu's detention, police searched his room in the east Jerusalem hostel in which he is staying. Officers confiscated documents and other materials.
[....]
Vanunu ended an 18-year prison term for treason in April, but was barred from leaving Israel. Security sources had said he was under surveillance on suspicion of giving unauthorized interviews to foreign media.
Do they mean this site?
Anyone who can live in a 3 by 2 cell for 18 years in solitary confinement can only be a war hero! This man is a superman, a great man a hero. Give him the freedom now! God is on your side Mordechai Vanunu you will go to heaven. But you will have heaven on earth first
What's up, Pat?
According to you, Vanunu must be "simply a conscientious objector to nuclear weapons" to have some credibility and he must not have a "much wider agenda". Could you call yourself "simply" anything, denying yourself "a much wider agenda"?
For instance could you call yourself "simply a Christian" and deny yourself the right to be, say, a philosopher or a University professor. Could you call yourself "simply a Jew" and deny yourself the right to be,say a Zionist or a comment-poster on Indymedia?
You say he "parrots all the standard anti-Israel vitriol which makes no effort to understand the dilemma that the Israelis are in as they seek to defend themselves against murder and mayhem".
Could you give us some examples please?
Also, after you have given loads of examples, could you ask yourself the question: What efforts has Pat O'Sullivan made to understand the dilemma the Palestinians are in? (hints: think occupation, exile, encirclement, victims of murder and mayhem at the hands of one of the top military powers in the world).
I'm puzzled by your objecting to "him quoting his "christianity" as a sort of shield and defence against the Jewish people".
1) Are you saying that Vanunu's christianity is not real (you put quotation marks around the word "christianity" when it refers to his christianity). Why? Are you professing to have a superior brand?
2) How has Mordechai used his christianity "as a sort of shield and defence against the Jewish people".
Are you saying that "the Jewish people" are attacking him? Do you know this for a fact about all Jewish people. What right would they all have to attack him? If he is attacked, has he any right, in your opinion, to defend himself?
How exactly has he used his christianity to defend himself against the attacks you presume are being made upon him by "the Jewish people"?
You tell us (from experience?) what Christianity, properly experienced, should lead one to do: "to love the Jews and seek their welfare" - and you do add, in case someone jumps in to remind you, "lack of love for Arabs" is in no way implied.
So, I take it that after an extensive study or maybe experience of Christianity, you decide that its positive function is to make its members "love the Jews and seek their welfare" and (much less positively) not to avoid love for Arabs.
Where exactly are you coming from, Pat?
I get a very strong feeling that it is you, not Mordechai, who has a much wider, and as yet hidden, agenda.
add your comments
An Israeli court today sentenced Mordechai Vanunu, who served 18 years for revealing nuclear secrets, to six months in prison for violating a ban on speaking to foreigners.
Mr Vanunu completed his sentence in 2004, and his parole terms forbade him from holding contacts with foreign nationals or giving interviews to the press.
[....]
Today, he was found guilty of giving interviews to international media outlets over the past three years.
"While returning a man to prison after he served 18 years there does not bring joy to anyone, there was no other choice but to take this step to make clear that the nation will defend its secrets and protect its security," the prosecutor, Dan Eldad, said in a statement issued by the justice ministry.
more at
http://www.guardian.co.uk/israel/Story/0,,2116746,00.html